Skip to content

Find 7 Best and Worst Homeowners Insurance Companies in Florida

Navigating the Waves: The 7 Best and Worst Homeowners Insurance Companies in Florida, USA

Owning a home in Florida isn’t always easy because you might have to deal with hurricanes and flooding. It’s really important to pick a good insurance company in Florida so you can take care of your house and not worry too much.

Best and Worst Homeowners Insurance Companies in Florida

We’re going to look at the top seven homeowners insurance companies in Florida, keeping in mind things like what kind of insurance they offer, if their customers are happy, and if the insurance company is financially strong.

The Best Homeowners Insurance Companies:

  1. State Farm:
    State Farm is often at the top when it comes to complete insurance and top-notch customer support. They’re a big deal in Florida, providing insurance that meets the specific demands of people who live there. This includes plans for hurricane damage and protection against floods.
  2. Citizens Property Insurance Corporation:
    Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, a government-supported insurer, provides critical insurance coverage for homeowners in Florida, particularly for those living in areas prone to high risks. Although Citizens might not be the leader in customer satisfaction, it offers insurance solutions when many private insurers might hold back.
  3. Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Company:
    Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Company stands out for its affordable prices and adaptable insurance options, making it a go-to insurer for those owning homes in Florida. They provide various policy plans that can be customized to fit the unique requirements of every homeowner.
  4. Tower Hill Insurance:
    Tower Hill Insurance is well-regarded for its solid financial foundation and tailor-made policies. They offer numerous coverage choices, which cover wind and hurricane damage too. It’s a dependable pick for Florida homeowners who are on the hunt for thorough insurance.
  5. Chubb:
    Chubb stands for upscale insurance and standout customer support. Their prices might be a bit steep, but Chubb’s policies are all-inclusive and built to offer prime defense. This makes them perfect for homeowners who put a high value on first-class coverage.
  6. American Integrity Insurance Company:
    American Integrity Insurance Company stands out as one of the top companies, thanks to its dedication to keeping customers happy and offering new types of coverage. They’re recognized for handling claims quickly and for providing services that fit the specific requirements of homeowners in Florida.
  7. Security First Insurance:
    Security First Insurance is known for putting their customers in the know and having clear policy details. They provide many different types of insurance and are proactive in helping homeowners deal with risks, especially those living where hurricanes are common.

The Worst Homeowners Insurance Companies:

  1. People’s Trust Insurance Company:
    People’s Trust Insurance Company has come under fire for the way it deals with claims and serves its customers. Many homeowners have shared stories of slow responses and arguments when trying to settle claims, earning it a not-so-great reputation among Florida insurers.
  2. Avatar Property & Casualty Insurance Company:
    Avatar Property & Casualty Insurance Company has struggled with financial stability, leading to concerns among policyholders. Homeowners looking for long-term reliability may want to explore other options.
  3. Universal Insurance Holdings, Inc.:
    Even though Universal Insurance Holdings, Inc. comes from a well-known company, it’s struggling with keeping customers happy. People who have insurance with them aren’t happy about how the company handles claims or talks to them, which makes them not such a great option.
  4. Florida Peninsula Insurance Company:
    Florida Peninsula Insurance Company gets both good and bad feedback. Some folks are ticked off about how it handles claims and what it won’t cover. If you’re thinking about this insurance for your home, make sure it’s really what you need first.
  5. Federated National Insurance Company:
    Federated National Insurance Company has been criticized for its handling of claims and lack of transparency. Homeowners seeking a reliable and communicative insurer may find better options elsewhere.
  6. Heritage Insurance:
    Heritage Insurance has struggled with keeping customers happy, especially when it comes to handling claims. Homeowners are having trouble with slow responses and getting their claims resolved which is worrying them about how quickly the company can act.
  7. St. Johns Insurance Company:
    St. Johns Insurance Company has received bad reviews for the way it deals with customer service and managing claims. If you’re a homeowner who wants a smooth process, it might be a good idea to look at different companies that focus on being quick and clear.


Picking a good house insurance company for your home in Florida is really important.

It means looking closely at what they cover, how happy their customers are, and if they’re financially solid. The top-notch ones have great policies and awesome customer service, but the bad ones could leave you annoyed and at risk.

To get through the tricky world of insurance companies, do your homework and ask around. This way, you’ll get one that’s just right for what you need.

Find your free compare rate quotes about cheap homeowners insurance for your family.